Oscar Blog: Diss-Position

Post a Comment
Return to Oscar Blog Home

Oscar Blog Post

Diss-Position

Posted Tue, Jan 22, 2008, 10:33 AM

[Note: This is one in a series of blog posts covering the Oscars for Yahoo! Movies. This blog is written by J. Keith van Straaten, and features opinion, news, interviews, and plenty of stuff with which you may disagree. New entries are generally posted on Monday afternoons, with responses to your comments posted throughout the week. Please add your comment below. To read the posts from the beginning, select OSCAR BLOG on the menu above, or click here.]

Oh, snap, Into The Wild!

You got served, Charlie Wilson's War!

In your face, Sweeney Todd: The Demon Barber of Fleet Street!  

The blogosphere is aflutter this morning with who got snubbed, dissed, and otherwise slapped in the face with virtual gloves by the folks who nominate other folks for Academy Awards.

You can (and will, I'm sure) make arguments for Angelina Jolie, Keira Knightley, James McAvoy, Eddie Vedder, and whomever else you enjoy.

And there are the usual legitimate reasons to gripe about the Academy -- and new ones too.  But I don't see the people who didn't get nominated as the real disses.  Not when you've got ones like this: 

• On its website, the Academy calls this morning's 5-minute display of nominees a "Nominations Announcement Show."  Some show... Kathy Bates and a bearded dude (okay, so he's president Sid Ganis) read names in front of five TV screens. E! was able to play the entire thing twice, with commercials. I'm now convinced they're trying to lower our expectations even further in case the Writers Guild strike makes the Oscar telecast as exciting as, well, the opening of an envelope.

• There were dozens of people who DID get nominated in categories that WILL get announced on the night of the awards but who weren't deemed worthy for that announcement this morning.  No cinematographers, no designers, no documentarians, no writers of music...

• Speaking of music, the Academy had already disqualified some of the best scores of the year, from There Will Be Blood, Into The Wild, and Enchanted. More on that in an upcoming post.

• Another amazing feat: The self-directing movie! Atonement gets a Best Picture nod, but no acknowledgement for its director.  Meanwhile, The Diving Bell and the Butterfly's Julian Schnabel gets a director nod, but no chance at Best Picture.

• OK, I will gripe about just a few absent nominees, just because I haven't yet heard others mention them... Not a word about Zodiac, The Lookout, and -- a much better comedy than Juno -- Knocked Up.  And if you ARE going to throw all these nominations at Juno (a point I will argue against in more detail in a later post), I would have liked to see one for the only actress who seemed to take to play the situation and not just the comedy: Jennifer Garner.

Yes, it was inevitable that someone was going to get dissed this morning.  But of course, it's also completely silly.  The Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences is not one person.  And at 80 years old, not a gossipy teen in junior high at that.  (More likely a cranky old man with a grudge and a bad memory.)

But it's not like the members of the Academy are out to pick the WORST movies of the year (for those nominees, look here). 

I suppose you do kind of wish (and only kind of) that the Academy would release a list of "others receiving votes," like they do in the NCAA rankings. Then you could know who really got absolutely no mention.  And then -- maybe -- you could make a legitimate claim of dissing.

Or you could just pass a note in study hall. 

I'm sure you already have your own disses to discuss(please, post a comment and let everybody know), and I'll have more as I race to the theatres to see all the nominees I haven't yet seen (and ones I've maybe forgotten about) before February 24th.

Let the arguing begin! 

Comments

Join the discussion. Here you'll see the comments in the order they were posted.
  • Agreed, Jennifer Garner should have been nominated. I loved her in Juno even though I didn't want to. I loved Juno, too and am SO glad it got nominated along with Ellen Page who I just want to eat up. Sure, the stylized script was a bit over the top. No one really talks like that. But I like Hollywood to give me things I wouldn't normally experience even if only via snarky-ish dialog. Sean Penn -- I feel his pain. Shoulda gotten a nod for sure! He tortured himself working the way he did on Into The Wild. And the score should have gotten a nod, too.

    Posted by: l_squared18 on Tue, Jan 22, 2008, 11:46 AM   [ Report Abuse ]
  • truehopedave productions just a clear vision american eagle!

    Posted by: roddystart on Tue, Jan 22, 2008, 9:13 PM   [ Report Abuse ]
  • The Great Debaters got sorely overlooked.

    Posted by: luvsexi on Wed, Jan 23, 2008, 10:38 AM   [ Report Abuse ]
  • No one saw Parker Posey in "Fay Grim," and that's a pity. Also, I never saw "In The Valley of Elah," but Tommy Lee Jones was the center of "No Country For Old Men," and deserved to be nominated for that.

    Posted by: dtapt on Wed, Jan 23, 2008, 10:39 AM   [ Report Abuse ]
  • Worst oversight for Best Actor - Chris Cooper in "Breach"

    Posted by: nina.seavey on Wed, Jan 23, 2008, 10:39 AM   [ Report Abuse ]
  • Hollywood is total BS. I refuse to watch the Oscars. I don't need some snooty morons to tell me what is good.

    Posted by: brntwdlos on Wed, Jan 23, 2008, 10:40 AM   [ Report Abuse ]
  • Who care about the Academy awards it a bunch of cattle auction after all. Are these actors lacking in self esteem that they need awards to boost thier low ego and esteems through these awards. We should be recognizing high achievers and a bunch of left wing loons.

    Posted by: tommiasoosai on Wed, Jan 23, 2008, 10:41 AM   [ Report Abuse ]
  • happy endings? will win documentary of the year next year

    Posted by: tarahurley on Wed, Jan 23, 2008, 10:42 AM   [ Report Abuse ]
  • What about "Pirates of the Caribbean?"

    Posted by: judy.simone on Wed, Jan 23, 2008, 10:42 AM   [ Report Abuse ]
  • Knocked Up was absolutely a better comedy than Juno. And I agree with you I_squared18, where's Sean Penn's nomination?!

    Posted by: rit3299 on Wed, Jan 23, 2008, 10:42 AM   [ Report Abuse ]

Post a Comment

You must be signed in to post a comment. Sign In

More Posts

Return to Oscar Blog

Subscribe to Oscar News

Oscar News from Yahoo! Movies
Oscar Blog from J. Keith van Straaten

Featured Photo

2008 Oscars Arrivals

Penelope Cruz, Marion Cotillard, Nicole Kidman and the rest of the night's stars hit the red carpet.

 

2008 Oscars Show

Look back at the best moment's from last night's Academy Awards ceremony.

 

2008 Press Room

Javier, Marion, Tilda and Daniel get photographed with their new friend, Oscar.

 

Oscar Poll

What was the biggest surprise of the night?

SPONSOR LINKS

Copyright ® 2008 Yahoo! Inc. All rights reserved. ACADEMY AWARDS®, OSCARS®, OSCAR NIGHT® and the OSCAR® design mark are the trademarks and service marks of the Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences. This site is neither endorsed by nor affliated with the Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences.
 
Terms of Service | Privacy Policy | Help